Magic: The Gathering · expansion
Recurring Nightmare
Exodus · #72 · rare · 1998
Enchantment
Listings
No active listings
From
—
Market reference
$85.30
TCGPlayer
Current listings on The Game Traders
No active listings for this card right now.
Card facts
Quick reference for collectors and graders.
- Collector number
- 72 / 143
- Release year
- 1998
- Rarity
- rare
- Illustrator
- Jeff Laubenstein
- Colors
- B
- Frame
- 1997
- Border
- black
- Finishes
- nonfoil
- Printed
- 1998-06-15
- Reserved list
- Yes
About this card
Mana cost: {2}{B}
Type: Enchantment
Sacrifice a creature, Return this enchantment to its owner's hand: Return target creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield. Activate only as a sorcery.
""I am confined by sleep and defined by nightmare." —Crovax"
Tournament legality
Current legal status across competitive formats.
Pricing reference
Latest snapshot from the upstream catalog. Actual marketplace prices fluctuate by condition, edition, and grade — use this as a reference, not a quote.
Scryfall pricing
| Variant | Price |
|---|---|
| USD (non-foil) | $85.30 |
| EUR (non-foil) | €58.52 |
| MTGO tix | 2.53 |
Frequently asked
How can I tell if my Recurring Nightmare is real?
Recurring Nightmare is not on our list of commonly-counterfeited cards, but counterfeits exist across every set. Check the print quality and cardstock (real cards have a distinctive blue inner core visible from the edge), the rosette pattern on the back, the security stamp on planeswalker / mythic cards from recent sets, and confirm the collector number and set code match the official Scryfall record. For high-value copies we recommend submitting to a professional grader (PSA, BGS, CGC) for tamper-evident authentication.
What is Recurring Nightmare worth?
As of the latest data, the current market reference price for Recurring Nightmare is $85.30; there are no active listings on The Game Traders right now. Actual value depends on condition, grading, edition and printing variant — graded high-condition copies (PSA 9–10) trade at a substantial premium over raw copies.
What set is Recurring Nightmare from?
Recurring Nightmare is from the Magic: The Gathering set "Exodus" in the expansion series, released in 1998.
What rarity is Recurring Nightmare?
Recurring Nightmare is a rare card in the Exodus set.
Watch on YouTube
Other Recurring Nightmare printings
Same Magic: The Gathering card across other sets and rarities.
